The Gossip - Music For Men

 The Gossip - Music For Men
 2/10

There’s no doubting Beth Ditto’s voice has a certain sting but let’s be honest, the reason The Gossip is popular is not because of their music. It’s because people are fascinated by the band’s obese lead singer, who has been painted by many in the entertainment media as some kind of freak. She’s posed naked for both Love and NME magazines and that’s just the start; she put herself in the spotlight and it worked once, but it’s doubtful it will work this time around. Beth Ditto’s weight is old news, now it’s time to let the music do the talking. Shamefully they can’t rely on their music, for without a new gimmick The Gossip has nothing to prove they’re worthy of the hype. Their attempts to revive the mid 2000s new rave scene are pitiful; trying the same old tricks without anything remotely progressive.

In Ditto’s own words, this is “predictable and typical” of a band stuck in time, 2006 to be precise, lacking ideas and the ability to work something new into their aging sound. Aside from the lead single ‘Heavy Cross’, which for a brief moment hints that The Gossip might finally have figured out a way to take advantage of Ditto’s powerful voice, Music For Men is totally cliché. Bouncy, repetitive guitar hooks sweep the floor on every song, the beats can’t even balance themselves on a straight floor and the vocals grate like a meowing Burmese cat. They’ve removed Ditto from the cover of the album and it just might be a big mistake. The Gossip needs the gimmick.


Nick

  • Anonymous Mon, 2009/06/22 - 8:29pm

    what a load of crap

    I love beth Ditto, she may be big but her voice beats one and most of the singers out at the current moment. And her voice in the new single is not based around her weight, it is pure brilliance, and to slander her weight is stupid and is basically just adding to the fact, just because she isn't stick thin she isn't good.

  • Dave Mon, 2009/06/22 - 10:01pm

    I don't think Nick is 'slandering her weight'

    He’s just pointing out that the media seem to focus on it (hopefully not missing the irony that he’s doing the same in his review). I think it’s harsh to assume that the size of the singer is the only reason they’re famous - their first couple of records are great and she has an amazing voice. But I agree this record is disappointing and dull.
  • Post new comment

    The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
References to Artrocker refer to content created before 21st October 2011 and are to be considered archived in light of the trademark registration of 'Artrocker'.

Rabbit, Rabbit All Day Long...

Top 5 Downloads

  • Bully For You

    Gorgeous Bully From: Plymouth, United Kingdom The more sanitised, synthetic and computerised mainstream music becomes the more the discerning music lover yearns for something a little more...
  • Johan Reinhold - Shoot Me Down Remix EP

    Having already garnered quite a following in his native Sweden, Johan Reinhold is introducing himself to our ears with his indie-electro-pop sensibilities in the form of a remix EP. Music after the...
  • Corpse Lights: A Curdled Churn

    Woe betide any unfortunate soul who suddenly has a flash of inspiration and records one of the most brilliant songs of the year in mid-December: it simply won’t even get heard amongst all...
  • The King Khan Experience

    I Love The Way You Howl King Khan recently retired The Shrines and The BBQ Show and started a new project – The King Khan Experience. He’s been getting compared to Jimi Hendrix his...
  • Secret Diaries: Parcel Delivery

    Secret Diaries have one of those supremely satisfying band names that make you wonder why no-one has thought of it before. I love it when that happens. And speaking of ‘supremely...

Latest News

Have You Read?

  • Hold Your Horse Is - Double B Side EP

    Another band with ‘horse’ in the title, the trio come from Surrey, and hope to one day organise a tour with other equine-related bands. Can I suggest Rapider Than Horsepower for the...
  • Guest top 10s: Penelope Edmund and KASMS

    Photo: Ian Arnold In one neat entry we combine the picks of KASMS and Penelope Edmund for their top artists of 2009.
  • Stag and Dagger Festival, Glasgow 2010

    I went to this festival last Saturday and the weather was real hot and I had been at work all day not enjoying the sun. Things didn’t get off to a blinder too as I was walking past the many...

Photos

  • In Pictures: FOE

    Photos from a recent FOE gig - a friend of our friends Hold Your Horse Is - she’s gonna be big!!! Read the gig review after the jump.
  • In Pictures: Avett Brothers

    Shots of North Carolina’s folk-rocking Avett Brothers’ stop in Glasgow - 22.08.11 Read the review of the gig here.
  • In Pictures: Latitude Festival 2011

    Take a look at the acts and art on offer at this year’s Latitude Festival in Suffolk. Included are the likes of Fight Like Apes, Lykke Li, Sea of Bees and Seasick Steve. Photos from our own...
  • In Pictures: Bad Guys at the Old Blue Last

    Good time with Bad Guys. Photos from the May 29th gig at the Old Blue Last. Read the review by the Bad Guy himself, Stuart London after the jump.  
  • In Pictures: White Lies and Crocodiles at Shepherd's Bush Empire

    Artrocker.com exclusive: for fans of White Lies and Crocodiles we’ve got some fresh pictures from their UK show at the Shepherd’s Bush Empire earlier this month, courtesy of Alessandro...

Blogs